How We Sold a Property Management Company for 10x EBITDA

How We Sold a Property Management Company for 10x EBITDA


Industry: Property Management
Location:
Chicago, Illinois
Established:
2009
Transaction Structure:
$15 Million Cash at Closing + $5–10 Million Performance-Based Earn-Out
Potential Total Transaction Value:
$25 Million
Potential Valuation:
Up to 10x EBITDA


The Company: A Rapidly Growing Property Management Platform

Founded in 2009, this Chicago-based property management company had established itself as a rapidly growing player in the residential property management industry.

At the time of the sale, the company managed more than 4,500 units and was on pace to expand its portfolio to 6,000 units. Its strong growth trajectory, established operating platform, and expanding portfolio made it an attractive acquisition target for strategic buyers looking to increase their market presence.

While the company had already built a substantial operation, its projected growth represented an opportunity to unlock additional value beyond what its historical financial performance alone might justify.


The Challenge: Capturing the Value of Future Growth

One of the biggest challenges when selling a rapidly growing business is ensuring the seller receives appropriate value for the company's future potential.

Traditional valuation methods often place significant emphasis on historical EBITDA. However, in this case, the company's accelerating growth and expanding portfolio presented an opportunity to command a premium valuation.

The objective was to structure a transaction that delivered substantial cash proceeds at closing while allowing the seller to participate financially in the company's continued success.


The Solution: Finding the Right Strategic Buyer

The company was ultimately acquired by a strategic buyer with an existing nationwide portfolio of more than 23,000 units under management.

The acquisition offered compelling strategic benefits, including an expanded geographic footprint, increased management scale, and the opportunity to leverage the buyer's existing infrastructure to support continued growth.

Rather than relying exclusively on a fixed purchase price based on historical earnings, the transaction incorporated a performance-based earn-out that aligned the interests of both parties.

This structure enabled the seller to receive a significant amount of cash at closing while preserving the opportunity to realize additional proceeds as the business achieved its growth objectives.


The Result: A Transaction Worth Up to $25 Million


The final transaction was structured as follows:

  • $15,000,000 in cash at closing, providing substantial immediate liquidity to the seller.
  • $5,000,000–$10,000,000 in potential earn-out consideration, contingent upon the company's continued growth.
  • $20,000,000–$25,000,000 in potential total proceeds, depending on future performance.
  • An effective valuation of up to 10x EBITDA if the company achieved its projected growth targets and the maximum earn-out was realized.

The transaction demonstrated how the right strategic buyer and a thoughtfully structured earn-out can create significant value for a business owner.

Rather than limiting the company's valuation to its historical earnings, the deal provided a mechanism for the seller to participate in the value of future growth.


Key Takeaway: The Right Buyer Can Make All the Difference


Not all buyers value a business the same way.

A financial buyer may focus primarily on historical profitability and a target return on investment. A strategic buyer, however, may recognize additional value through geographic expansion, operational synergies, increased market share, and future growth opportunities.

In this case, identifying a strategic acquirer with an established national platform helped create a transaction that balanced immediate liquidity with substantial additional upside.


The result was a sale that delivered $15 million in cash at closing, with the potential to reach $25 million in total consideration and an EBITDA multiple as high as 10x.


For owners of rapidly growing businesses, this transaction illustrates an important principle:


The value of your business isn't necessarily limited to what you've already accomplished. With the right buyer and deal structure, you may also be able to get paid for where your business is going.



By Dustin Sigall • July 3, 2026
Sold: Food Safety Service - Established 25 Years
By Dustin Sigall • May 5, 2026
How we Closed a $5.5M Commercial Flooring Deal at 4.3x EBITDA with Rolled Equity in Just 5 Months
By Dustin Sigall • April 18, 2026
Overview Industry: Digital Marketing (Financial Sector / PR & Content) Founded: 2016 Employees: 30 (full-time, part-time, and contractors) Transaction Year: 2022 Adjusted Earnings: $382,000 Asking Price: $1.2M (3.14x multiple) The Situation The seller founded the agency in 2016 and successfully scaled it from the ground up to a team of 30. By 2020, the business was performing well and positioned for further growth. After conducting a detailed growth analysis with her business coach, the seller mapped out a clear path to the next stage—complete with the required time, capital, and staffing. While the opportunity was attractive, she ultimately decided she did not want to take on the demands of scaling the business further. Like many entrepreneurs, she recognized her strength was in building and growing businesses—but not necessarily operating them at the next level. Preparation & Strategy The seller engaged us in 2021 to begin the sale process. The initial phase focused on positioning the business for a successful exit: Cleaned and normalized financials to ensure clarity and credibility Clearly defined owner responsibilities and team structure Identified the ideal buyer profile and strategic fit Developed a targeted go-to-market strategy Through market analysis and comparable transactions, we established a valuation of $1.2M, representing a 3.14x multiple of adjusted earnings. Market Response Once brought to market, the business generated strong interest: 233 buyer inquiries 152 signed NDAs 5 qualified offers This level of activity validated both the quality of the business and the effectiveness of the positioning strategy. Buyer Selection The seller ultimately chose an existing agency owner as the buyer. While several offers presented stronger financial terms, this buyer stood out due to: Relevant industry experience Complementary service offerings A clear vision for scaling the business The acquiring agency provided broader digital marketing services, while the seller’s firm specialized in financial-sector content and PR. This created a strong strategic fit and clear synergy. Deal Structure & Negotiation The accepted offer met the full asking price of $1.2M, but included a notable structure: 60% seller financing This is significantly higher than typical transactions, where seller financing more commonly ranges between 10%–20%, if included at all. The buyer’s rationale was to preserve capital for immediate growth initiatives post-acquisition. While other offers included more favorable upfront cash terms, they lacked the strategic alignment and operational expertise the seller prioritized. After extensive discussions, the seller chose to move forward based on: Confidence in the buyer’s ability and integrity Desire to see the business continue to grow Commitment to employees and clients Outcome The decision proved successful: The business has continued to grow post-sale Employees and clients experienced a smooth transition The buyer has consistently made payments on the seller note, which is now nearly paid off Key Takeaways Strategic fit can outweigh stronger financial terms Seller financing can unlock the right buyer when structured thoughtfully Preparation and positioning drive competitive buyer interest Alignment of values (team, clients, legacy) is often critical in final decision-making Testimonial From Seller "I met Matt through a successful entrepreneur at my business coaching group. She had recently sold her business and found freedom. I knew I wanted to do the same. She told me about her experience with Matt, so I reached out to him about selling my firm. To be honest, my firm was pretty unsellable at that point, but Matt spent a year with me cleaning up the books, improving the value, marketing the business and finding the perfect buyer. There were a few times I almost gave up or lowered the price, but Matt kept us on track and we found the perfect buyer and got our asking price. Matt is trustworthy, reliable, experienced and has a tireless work ethic. The most important characteristic is his calming force throughout a stressful process. I knew I could count on him and trust him to get me to the finish line. Now I have my life back and money in the bank. So thankful to have met Matt!"
By Dustin Sigall • April 3, 2026
Closed at 4.3x EBITDA in Less Than 6 Months A retiring owner of a highly profitable niche design and manufacturing company engaged SD Business Advisors to find the right buyer — not just any buyer. Seller’s Goals Cash out 85% of equity Retain 15% ownership Stay on post-sale as a design employee Key Challenge This was a highly specialized opportunity requiring a buyer with both: Strong business operations experience Relevant design sensibility and industry fit Additional complexity included: All fabrication was subcontracted, creating perceived continuity risk under new ownership The seller wanted a partial equity rollover , requiring a buyer aligned with a more sophisticated deal structure Our Process 150 buyer inquiries generated 80 signed NDAs 3 qualified offers received The Result We successfully identified and closed with a buyer who had the right mix of operational capability, design alignment, and comfort with the seller’s continued involvement. Outcome: ✔ Sold at 4.3x EBITDA ✔ Closed in under 6 months ✔ Seller achieved liquidity, retained upside, and stayed involved in the business Client Feedback “Todd communicated quickly and efficiently and found the buyer that was not only qualified, but who also had an affinity for what we do… I have never experienced the quality of buyers that I did working with Todd.”
By Mark Flores • March 3, 2026
WHY CONTRACTORS NEED A SPECIALIZED ADVISOR WHEN IT'S TIME TO SELL
By Matt McDonald • March 3, 2026
15 CRITICAL MISTAKES TO AVOID WHEN SELLING YOUR BUSINESS
By Dustin Sigall • February 20, 2026
Understanding the true value of your business is one of the most important and often misunderstood parts of ownership. At its core, business valuation answers one fundamental question: What would a knowledgeable, willing buyer pay for this busi ness today? The answer is rarely as simple as a multiple you saw online or what a competitor sold for last year. Real valuation blends financial performance, risk, growth potential, and market demand. Two businesses with identical revenue can have dramatically different valuations. Why? Buyers evaluate business fundamentals as much as any financial metrics. Key value drivers include: Consistent and growing cash flow Diversified customer base Recurring or contracted revenue Strong management team Clean financials and documented processes Low owner dependency Favorable industry trends Stable margins Conversely, risks such as customer concentration, inconsistent earnings, or owner-centric operations reduce value. Business valuation is not just a formula. It is a blend of data, judgement, and real-world transaction experience. Business owners tend to focus on the overall potential selling price while the deal structure is of equal importance. An all cash transaction will likely carry a different value than a structure that includes seller financing, an earn-out, working capital adjustments, or seller equity roll. The best time to understand your company's value is before you plan to sell. Early valuation allows time to fix weaknesses, increase profitability, and position your business for a stronger exit. Business valuation is not a one-time event. It is an ongoing measurement of how attractive your company is to buyers at any given time. Owners who treat valuation as a strategic tool, rather than a last-minute requirement, consistently achieve better outcomes. If you're asking yourself, "How much is my business worth?", it's never too early to find out. Whether your business is located in San Diego or anywhere else, our team of experienced advisors is happy to provide a free and confidential business valuation. We sell businesses nationwide. Please fill out the form below to get the process started.
By Dustin Sigall • February 4, 2026
Navigating Negotiations
By Dustin Sigall • February 4, 2026
Your CPA (probably) valued your business wrong
August 18, 2022
When Selling a Business, Relationships Matter